The Lie We Tell on LinkedIn: Understanding Cognitive Dissonance in Leadership

By Tony Grayson Tech Executive (ex-SVP Oracle, AWS, Meta) & Former Nuclear Submarine Commander

The moment the story breaks, cognitive dissonance occurs when our self-image as a 'servant leader' clashes with our selfish actions.

Scroll through your LinkedIn feed right now. You will see an endless parade of posts about "Servant Leadership," "Radical Candor," and "Empathy." We curate these digital avatars to look like benevolent sages, immune to ego, and to put the team before self.

And on our worst days, we actually believe it.

But science tells a different story.

You are wired to be selfish.

Despite what you post, preach, or believe about yourself, your biological default setting is self-preservation. Recognizing this isn't cynicism; it is the first step toward actual emotional intelligence. Cognitive dissonance in leadership occurs when we refuse to admit this biological reality, creating a blind spot that makes you the most dangerous person in the room.

The Biology of Self-Interest: Your Brain is Not a Team Player

Evolution did not optimize your brain for "corporate synergy" or "stakeholder value." It optimized you for survival.

Shutterstock

When you face a threat, whether it’s a saber-toothed tiger in the Paleolithic era or a critique of your Q3 strategy in a boardroom, your amygdala fires before your prefrontal cortex ever comes online.

You defend. You deflect. You attack.

This isn’t a choice; it’s a biological reflex known as an Amygdala Hijack. Research in evolutionary psychology suggests that what we call "altruism" is often just a sophisticated form of cooperation designed to enhance our own status. True selflessness requires overriding millions of years of hardware programming.

Your biological hardware isn't built for corporate synergy; it's built for survival. The amygdala processes threats and triggers defensive reflexes milliseconds before your rational brain even knows what's happening.

The Mismatch Hypothesis: Dominance vs. Prestige

Why do we react so aggressively to minor work issues? Psychologists call this the Evolutionary Mismatch Hypothesis.

Our brains evolved in an environment where social exclusion meant death. In a small tribe, if you lost status, you didn't eat. Today, we navigate complex hierarchies in massive organizations, yet our hardware hasn't kept pace.

When a subordinate questions your decision, your brain doesn't see "constructive feedback." It sees a threat to your status in the tribe. Your cortisol spikes, your vision narrows, and you shift into Dominance mode.

Leadership Style	The Mechanism	The Reality
Dominance	Status through force, fear, or hoarding information.	Your Default (Self-Preservation)
Prestige	Status through competence, generosity, and teaching.	Your Aspiration (Social Learning)

Most leaders fake Prestige on social media but revert to Dominance the moment their ego is threatened.

The Mechanism: Understanding Cognitive Dissonance in Leadership

How do we reconcile our selfish, dominance-based instincts with our desire to be "good people"?

We lie to ourselves.

The engine of self-deception: When your selfish actions clash with your 'servant leader' self-image, your brain generates mental discomfort. To fix it, you rationalize the behavior rather than changing it.

This is the engine of cognitive dissonance in leadership. When your actions (acting out of self-interest) conflict with your self-image (being a selfless leader), your brain experiences psychological discomfort. To fix it, you create a narrative to bridge the gap.

The  Fundamental Attribution Error powers this:

• When I mess up: It is because of the situation ("I yelled because I’m under a lot of stress right now").

• When YOU mess up: It is because of your character ("You yelled because you are unprofessional").

We grant ourselves infinite grace and others none.

• The Situation: You micromanaged a project because you were afraid of looking bad to the Board.

• The Story You Tell: "I was just ensuring quality control because the team is inexperienced."

We believe we can do no wrong because our brains rewrite history in real-time to protect our egos.

The Path Out: Failure, Thinking, and Coaching

You cannot fix a problem you refuse to acknowledge. Breaking the cycle of self-protection doesn't happen naturally. It requires three specific friction points to override your biology.

1. Catastrophic Failure

Often, it takes a massive failure where your "stories" no longer hold up against reality to shatter the illusion of your own perfection. When the results are undeniable, the ego has nowhere to hide. This is why I often say you don't know your team—or yourself—until the alarm sounds.

2. Deep Reflection (The Pause)

You must learn to insert a pause between the stimulus (the threat) and the response (the self-protection). That pause is where leadership lives. It is the moment you feel the anger rising and choose to ask a question instead of issuing a command.

3. Ruthless Coaching

You cannot see your own blind spots. By definition, they are invisible to you. You need a coach or a mentor who doesn't buy your narrative—someone who loves you enough to tell you that you are the problem.

Stop pretending you aren’t selfish. Admit that you are—and then do the hard work to override that reflex in service of the mission and your people.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is cognitive dissonance in leadership?

Cognitive dissonance in leadership occurs when a leader's actions contradict their values. For example, a leader who preaches "transparency" but hides critical information will rationalize this behavior to avoid feeling like a hypocrite.

Why is evolutionary psychology important for management?

It explains why humans react irrationally to stress. Understanding the "fight or flight" response helps leaders recognize when they are reacting out of fear rather than logic.

How can I stop being a selfish leader?

Recognize your triggers. When you feel defensive, pause. Seek feedback from people who are not afraid to offend you.

____________________________________

Tony Grayson is a recognized Top 10 Data Center Influencer, a successful entrepreneur, and the President & General Manager of Northstar Enterprise + Defense.

A former U.S. Navy Submarine Commander and recipient of the prestigious VADM Stockdale Award, Tony is a leading authority on the convergence of nuclear energy, AI infrastructure, and national defense. His career is defined by building at scale: he led global infrastructure strategy as a Senior Vice President for AWS, Meta, and Oracle before founding and selling a top-10 modular data center company.

Today, he leads strategy and execution for critical defense programs and AI infrastructure, building AI factories and cloud regions that survive contact with reality.

Read more at: tonygraysonvet.com